: 4519 | 107633 | 12162

Bring back the Sandbox on developerWorks 
Use this IdeaSpace on how to improve the Lotus section of the developerWorks site.

: 64
: 64
: 0
: Lotus Technical Information / Other
: notes.net, developerworks
: Peter von Stöckel2646 03 Dec 2010
: / Email
In September 2010, IBM removed the Sandbox from developerWorks Lotus. With that removal, they also broke countless forum responses that link to specific Sandbox files, as well as links from countless blogs and web sites all over the world.
There are two ways to fix this. Either put the Sandbox back to where it was before, and thereby restore all broken links. The other way is to put it on OpenNTF, and make sure that every link to the old Sandbox is properly redirected to the same document on OpenNTF.
There are still lots of useful code and examples in the Sandbox, for both new and experienced developers and administrators, even if it's several years old by now, and I fail to see a good reason to remove it.
For the time being, the Sandbox can be accessed on my site: http://www.bananahome.com/ldd/sandbox.nsf

1) Carl Tyler5443 (03 Dec 2010)
Totally agree
2) Gregg Eldred5345 (03 Dec 2010)
As I recall, IBM withdrew the Lotus Redbooks, then told us "wait, we will have the same great information to you in a wiki." Meanwhile, months went by before we saw any hint of a wiki. Now, they remove the Sandbox. Whether they take your advice or not, months will go by before there is any apparent movement toward OpenNTF or whatever replaces it (or not). While not perfect, it was still a very useful resource. And what do we have now? Nothing.

I want to make it clear that I am not throwing stones at OpenNTF. What I am ranting about is the removal of a resource without an immediate alternative. If you knew that in 2010 you were going to remove the Sandbox, then you should plan for an alternative.

And fix the TechNotes that refer to the Sandbox. Like this one, for example:

{ Link }

3) Peter Presnell26490 (10 Dec 2010)
I would like to see the resource consolidated with OpenNTF so there is a single source for all the "free" code. There may be intellectual property issues with the content of SandBox, but probably no more than exists with all the old OpenNTF projects that continue to be hosted.
4) Giulio C686 (16 Dec 2010)
The sandbox is a great place to easily deploy simple solutions. Rather than keeping Sandbox totally separate, it could be viewed as sub-system of OpenNTF.

I make this relationship because Sandbox applications are very simple projects and to unify it under one location reduces the fragmentation of ideas through disparate sites. Another reason I think they are related is that Sandbox applications are OpenNTF projects before the become "projects". So you can get the app out there, and should more functionality be needed it can be converted into a project.

So, OpenNTF is really the Sandbox on steroids. But having the old sandbox provides a means to follow the natural progression of an application from an idea to a more serious implementation if required.

But the sandbox should not clutter OpenNTF projects. Some distinction will still need to be made between a Sandbox app, and a project, as I would think only a fraction of apps actually become projects. Otherwise it will get "noisy" and dilute the benefits of projects in OpenNTF.
5) David Hablewitz14210 (29 Mar 2011)
It takes more wisdom than I have to see the benefit of taking this away.
That's the politically correct way of saying that taking the sandbox away makes absolutely no sense.
6) Bill Malchisky8868 (06 Apr 2011)
Although I don't code as much these days, even for admins the sand box proved to be a gem for utilities time and again. It is a treasure trove for developers. Reintroduce that gem of a place.
7) Michael Ward10 (14 Sep 2012)
IBM needs to re-host the sandbox due to the fact that there are hundreds, no thousands of different postings on IBM's sites and many other public sites that reference links to the sandbox for code to fix or find problems etc. I am glad I have a local copy.


Welcome to IdeaJam™

You can run IdeaJam™ in your company. It's easy to install, setup and customize. Your employees, partners and customers will immediately see results.

Use IdeaJam to:

  • Collect ideas from employees
  • Solicit feedback and suggestions from employees and customers
  • Run innovation contests and competitions
  • Validate concepts
  • Use the power of "crowd-sourcing" to rank ideas and allow the best ideas to rise to the top

IdeaJam™ works with:

  • IBM Connections
  • IBM Lotus Quickr
  • Blogs and Wikis
  • Websphere Portal
  • Microsoft Sharepoint
  • and other applications.

IdeaJam has an extensive set of widgets and API's that allow you to extend and integrate IdeaJam™ with other applications.

Learn more about IdeaJam >>

XWork Server Community Edition
allow copying file path from database properties infobox
provide admin tool to force-stop Amgr & Runonserver tasks
use one column value in another column
get a list of readers and authors for the selected document
Support for very high log activity in HTTP server
Clicking the Quickflag icon on an already flagged e-mail should remove the flag
use @Newline in @Failure text
Inbox Zero for Notes
Integrate Worklight into Designer
Domino Designer available for Linux and MAC Os
When inserting a new row into a table: take current format of the neighbour rows
modify, copy, paste multiple ACL entries at once
I wish evaluate() would throw errors (again)
I wish @Eval returned errors much like other @Functions
make profile a first class design element again
Simple archive settings => all docs of 2009, ....
Tune out of conversation
Archiving Emails (Selection Criteria)
Wiki Archive
more options to program customized view setup & changes
I wish NotesUi objects could open an ACL dialog
put back script library alias
NSD Kill for specific task or PID

IdeaJam developed by